Are university lectures still relevant?

Lately, there’s been quite a few articles (such as here and here) discussing the use of the university lecture and its perceived shortcomings. The question is asked: is the lecture an unengaging relic from before the digital age? Are lectures really the best way to learn? I attended many lectures throughout my undergraduate studies, and have also tried out massive open online courses (MOOCs) from providers such as Coursera. To be perfectly honest, I don’t mind lectures at all. While they could be dull at times, they had the advantage of sitting you in a room where information was being fed to you whilst you were (mostly) shielded from the distractions of the outside world. Having a timetable of lectures was a powerful way to organise your learning (especially as you were paying for this education). It takes a lot of motivation to sit through a fraction of the lectures each week from online courses.

On the other hand, I have found some course material much easier to digest when it is presented in a more dynamic way than the traditional lecture can provide. For instance, my present work requires that I acquire a better understanding of computer vision. I would find it very difficult to sit through a long lecture involving probability, maths, etc – and a lot of it would quickly go over my head. Recently, I found a course online called “Artificial Intelligence for Robotics” offered for free by Udacity. Instead of long, uninterrupted lectures, each learning unit is composed of 20-30 short (2-3 minute) videos. At the end of each video, the footage is replaced by a text editor, where I have to implement right away what I learned in the lecture before could I proceed. While before I could find it easy to speed up or daydream during talks on this subject, suddenly every second mattered because I was about to be tested right away and build something tangible with the knowledge I had attained. These modules served as both lecture and tutorial at the same time. After each video segment, my code would continue to grow as I continued to add features, and at the end of each unit, I had a program that I could go back to reference in the future.

Out of all the tertiary learning styles I’ve experienced so far, I have found the short video then test/coding method the most enjoyable and interesting way to learn. I don’t know if it will ever completely replace the formal lecture, but I think we’ll see it adopted more and more frequently by online learning institutions in the future.

 

The following two tabs change content below.
Computational biology PhD candidate at the Australian National University. I love writing (both articles and software), learning more about the world around us, and beekeeping. I also write for BioSky.co

Latest posts by Jack Simpson (see all)

Comments are closed.